Fresh babble here! Innocent bystanders Stale babble here Who's to blame Zander's Tangle Last babble Last babble Next babble Next babble
profile
Zander Nyrond
Name: Zander Nyrond
Log of Smallship One - Passionate and Confused - Bonekickers
What a long, strange drip he's been...
smallship1
[info]smallship1
Add to Memories
Tell a Friend
Bonekickers
Much scorn being poured on this first episode by Serious Scientific People. Personally, I liked it and will be watching.

I never really thought they were going to do a serious dramatic version of one of those "oh look, we've found a small brown lump of something, this is tremendously significant since it proves there were people living in Cheltenham in the Middle Ages" programmes that the Countess loves to shout at so much. There are, after all, plenty of real ones, and even those have resorted to making wilder and wilder assumptions in a desperate attempt to make themselves sound interesting to the average pleb like me. "Was the Amesbury Archer the King Of Stonehenge?!?!!" So I was primed for something that was not entirely plausible in the real world, and since that's what I look for in fiction I wasn't disappointed.

There was mysticism, but no magic, unless you count the fact that it took the cross with the broken arm significantly longer to catch fire than the others. (I was a little let down by the reset button, even though I was expecting it. Some day I'd like to see one of these things where the sacred relic isn't destroyed/buried/flooded/taken to another dimension at the end, and the world has to get used to the fact that something strange does exist. And I'd like it written by someone who has neither a specifically religious nor an atheist agenda, please.) There was a neat little reference when First Loony, with sword and long billowy coat, lopped off someone's head and staggered back against a wall and for a split second I *almost* expected lightning and smashing windows. And there are interesting characters, at least on first viewing. It will remain to be seen whether they can keep it from getting too samey.

And, of course, it also had the huge advantage of not being nuWho. :)
Comments
hobbitblue From: [info]hobbitblue Date: July 9th, 2008 11:20 am (UTC) (Link to babble)
Not watched it yet, that's a treat for later today, but given the ad campaign on television (which whetted my appetite nicely) I can't believe anyone would think it was going to be a serious dramatic anything about archaelogy. Torchwood meets Indiana Jones, I thought while rubbing my hands gleefully in anticipation.
aunty_marion From: [info]aunty_marion Date: July 9th, 2008 12:29 pm (UTC) (Link to babble)
There's one good thing about the characters which I've only just recognised. I can actually TELL THEM APART. Which in a lot of things I find difficult (this face-non-recognition thing keeps kicking in). I've been put off a lot of things because there were (say) too many tall dark men all wearing similar clothes.

...It's a wonder I wasn't put off Star Trek, thinking about that. We only had black & white telly in them days, and it took me several episodes to notice Spock's pointed ears, and of course red, gold, and blue all look very similar shades of grey in black and white...
soren_nyrond From: [info]soren_nyrond Date: July 9th, 2008 01:03 pm (UTC) (Link to babble)
IMHO, if it *was* the True one, it wouldn't have burned.

And, given that there are at least 10 organisations claiming to be the One True Descendants of the KTs, I'd like to have seen something more substantially linked in than a looney televangelist and 2 orphan boys.

Okay to the thunder and lightning point.
Query: was this even plausible in their world ?
keristor From: [info]keristor Date: July 9th, 2008 02:25 pm (UTC) (Link to babble)
You may be interested in the BBC News article (and the following comments) on the episode. I'm wondering whether to download it, or not to bother...
iamza From: [info]iamza Date: July 9th, 2008 03:19 pm (UTC) (Link to babble)
I forgot that this was on until the show had already half aired, but I loved the half I got to see enough that I plan on downloading the show from iplayer. Bonekickers reminds me a lot of Indiana Jones adventures, or that Tia Carrere Relic Hunter TV series from a few years ago, both of which I enjoyed (though perhaps admitting the last is not entirely wise, heh).
edenwhore From: [info]edenwhore Date: July 10th, 2008 11:52 am (UTC) (Link to babble)
it was the dodgy archeaological practices that got most people. ( "one two three PULL" ?? Argh ! ).And the awful acting. And the religious nutcases, who were done very badly. I turned it off after 40 mins, now I wish I'd seen the ending, I could have done with a laugh after all that...
And if it's ok to wander round Bath in broad daylight carrying a massive sword, then I might move back there.... >:)
What they all said (6) . Unless... You wanted to say something?